In Dubious Battle (2016)
In 1930s California, activist Mac McLeod and young Jim Nolan infiltrate a group of 900 impoverished apple pickers whose wages have been unfairly cut. They aim to organize a widespread labor action against the powerful growers’ association. As the workers unite, the peaceful protest soon gives way to escalating tension and violent confrontations, forcing Jim to confront the brutal ethics of revolution and leadership.
Length: 1h54m
Genre: Drama, Social Realism
This Title is: An impassioned look at class conflict and labor activism
Cast
Nat Wolff, James Franco, Vincent D’Onofrio, Selena Gomez, Robert Duvall
Parental Guidance
Maturity Rating: R – for some violence and brief sexuality
FAQ
- Is In Dubious Battle (2016) Based on a True Story?: No, but it is adapted from John Steinbeck’s novel, which fictionalizes the historical 1933 fruit worker strike in California’s Tulare County.
- Where was In Dubious Battle (2016) filmed?: Filming took place in the Atlanta, Georgia area, specifically Bostwick and Senoia.
- Who Wrote the Soundtrack?: Volker Bertelmann
Filmmaker Profile
James Franco directed this ambitious adaptation of John Steinbeck’s challenging 1936 debut novel. Franco is noted for his commitment to bringing esteemed, complex literary pieces to the screen, demonstrating an ongoing passion for social commentary and American history throughout his diverse body of work.
Why It’s Worth Watching
This production offers a raw, striking portrait of economic injustice during the Depression era. The ensemble acting is truly exceptional, especially the chemistry between the charismatic leaders and the desperate community they serve. The presentation masterfully captures the volatile atmosphere of desperation and the unwavering human spirit fighting for fairness.
Main Character Deep Dive
Jim Nolan, played by Nat Wolff, begins his journey as an eager, naive youth seeking structure and purpose within the political movement. We see his transformation as he faces the ruthless realities of organizing the workers. His central conflict involves grappling with the manipulation required for the cause, resulting in a performance that vividly showcases the loss of innocence under immense political pressure.
Unforgettable Quote
“Everything’s been a mess, all my life. I want to work toward something.”
Trivia
- The source material, the John Steinbeck novel, is considered the first part of his “Dustbowl Trilogy,” preceding the acclaimed works *Of Mice and Men* and *The Grapes of Wrath*.
- The title is a specific reference to a line in John Milton’s epic 17th-century poem, *Paradise Lost*.
- Director James Franco previously directed adaptations of other major literary works, including William Faulkner’s *As I Lay Dying*.
Trailer
Stream In Dubious Battle (2016) on:
Our Review
- Quality:
- Acting:
- Storyline:
- Visuals:
- Entertainment:
I was immediately drawn into the stark, powerful setting of 1930s California. The picture’s visual presentation is exceptional, creating a deeply tangible atmosphere of dust and hardship that immediately grounds the viewer in the time period. The acting across the board is outstanding; I particularly admired the raw energy that Nat Wolff and James Franco brought to their roles as labor organizers. The story handles the workers’ struggle with great weight, showing both the unity and the confusion inherent in a righteous cause. It is a stirring portrayal of the price of social change, and the stakes feel genuinely high throughout the running time. The direction ensures that every confrontation is intensely dramatic and emotionally resonant. This production is a strong testament to the power of American literature and the timeless quest for justice. The recreation of the era is meticulous, making it an experience that stays with you.
Who Should Watch This?
Stream it if you appreciate ambitious literary adaptations focusing on American history and social issues, supported by an impressive, dedicated ensemble of performers.
